UK police threatening filesharers with 10 years in prison and unlimited fine

Today I was made aware of the takedown of UK music sharing website and the aggressive message that the Serious Organised Crime Agency placed on the site in order to frighten its 70,000 users. I was appalled and have written the following letter of complaint, which I have sent both to SOCA and the Independent Police Complaints Commission. Wonder what the response will be?

The takedown message that SOCA put on on 14th February is misleading, threatening, and shows a conflict of interests where there should be neutrality.

Can SOCA explain why the message reads like a cross between a bully’s threat and a music industry press release? Can they explain precisely what their source is to back up their claim that having downloaded a file illegally someone has damaged the music industry? is popular with a demographic consisting mainly of young black men – a demographic already alienated and wary about law enforcement. SOCA’s stance is to treat these music fans like hardened criminals, threatening them with a prison sentence twice as long as that of a repeat-offending child rapist.

If SOCA is using the IFPI’s claim of £15m yearly losses to justify this threat, have they asked the IFPI for evidence of this, or have they simply believed it without question? The IFPI’s claim is clearly a gross distortion and for SOCA to simply believe and promote this claim is ludicrous and irresponsible.

Dan Bull

You may also like...

3 Responses

  1. Chayse says:

    Well. That’s not good at all.

  2. hello to the folks of Dan Bulls world of geeky rapology,

    how are more people not raging about this !!!!! the internet is supposed to be one of the last stands for true free speech and yet more and more people are unwilling to point out there views so Dan i appreciate what you are doing with your letter and i hope you manage to get a reply, as they have allot to answer for and list time i checked they do work for us all right ?

  3. Brad says:

    Just because you download a file “illegally” doesn’t mean you damage the music industry. For every 1 person that pirates a song about 10 people pay for it and also some people will pirate a song to see if they like it before paying for it

Leave a Reply